• Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Flickr
  • YouTube
Thinking Out Loud

Why Tenure Matters

by Michael Jinkins | Sep 17, 2013

The dramatic countryside of Northeastern Scotland along the craggy banks of the Don River, a wild stream that tumbles from the Highlands to the North Sea, may account to some degree for the flinty character of this region's famous son, William Robertson Smith. The warmth of the family hearth in the village of Keig, Aberdeenshire, may account for his sweetness of spirit, even amid the trials he eventually endured. But nothing accounts for his genius.

A linguistic prodigy, Smith learned Latin, Greek, and Hebrew as a child. After studying at New College, Edinburgh, Smith traveled to Germany, learning from legendary scholars such as the great Albrecht Ritschl. It was in Germany that Smith became acquainted with the newly emerging approaches to biblical criticism. This was the mid-nineteenth century, and biblical scholarship, especially in Germany, was exploding. Scholars were eagerly tracing out the implications of applying scientific, historical, and literary methods to the study of biblical texts.  

By the age of twenty-four, Smith was named Professor of Oriental Languages and Old Testament Exegesis at the Free Church Theological College (subsequently known as Christ College) in Aberdeen. Smith's inaugural lecture was on "what history teaches us to seek for in the Bible."  

Smith's reputation as a scholar and his writing ability attracted the attention of the editors of the ninth edition of the Encyclopedia Britannica. They asked him to write several articles, including one on the Bible, in which he introduced to a British audience the fruits of historical criticism of the biblical text. The Free Church of Scotland, in which Smith was ordained, took considerable exception to Smith's scholarship. The article on the Bible was published in 1875. In 1877, Smith was suspended from teaching. In 1880, he was formally tried for heresy. And in 1881, he was removed from his professorship by the church.  

Were you or I to read his article on the Bible today we would hardly find its conclusions surprising. What Smith and others were discovering then has become commonplace now. But "The Bible" and other articles such as his respected essay on "Sacrifice" (which represents one of the first ever forays into the field we have come to call "comparative religion," an approach to the study of religions now taught in many seminaries) were revolutionary in Smith's time, and the ideas he explored were considered dangerous to the faith and tranquility of the church.  

After being dismissed from his teaching post in Aberdeen, Smith was hired by the University of Cambridge where he taught and served as librarian. He also went on to serve as the Editor of The Encyclopedia Britannica. Though his trial for heresy and dismissal from his professorship were traumatic to him and his family, I would argue that these actions were even more costly to the church, which retreated even deeper into pious timidity on one hand and on the other hand a posture of threat against its next generation of scholars (including Marcus Dods and A.B. Bruce).  

Scholarship sometimes moves us along with little friction, one discovery following upon another to the applause of all concerned. But sometimes scholarship shocks us, turns our assumptions upside down, makes us question cherished beliefs and reorganize our ways of viewing the world - and God. Both scholarly paths can lead to truth. Both can lead to errors. Many the time when people have applauded hoary scholarship that foundered on its own pious clichés. Many the time too when rebels without a clue published their radical ideas which, when the dust finally settled, turned out to be worthless. But scholarship that is fettered has little chance to move anyone forward. And scholarship that is told it must not question its subject because its subject is sacred, ultimately is unlikely to edify.  

The reason theological schools came in time to value academic tenure was to ensure that the research of our William Robertson Smiths would flourish. Tenure exists to protect academic freedom and to encourage vigorous and adventurous scholarship. It is intended to promote a spirit of exploration and discovery. It is meant to guarantee that scholars and teachers cannot be dismissed just because their research uncovers uncomfortable ideas.  

By extension, however, there is an assumption in the granting of tenure that it will be used for the advancement of knowledge. Tenure is not a blanket guarantee of life-long employment, but it is a guarantee of due process. This guarantee is intended to protect academic freedom so that scholars can produce their scholarship without being cowed by threats to job security should their scholarship go in a direction that challenges norms. Of course, a scholar need not produce shocking scholarship to deserve tenure. But tenure does assume that the scholar will be productive. 

Several years ago I dropped by the office of a friend who served on the faculty of a theological school then in the throes of ecclesiastical controversy. Some professors at the school had already paid the ultimate professional price for their scholarship's transgressing the boundaries of a rigidly enforced "orthodoxy."  I had just bought a copy of my friend's newest book. Handing it to him to sign, I asked, "So, tell me about your new book!" He took the book from my hands, signed it, and shrugged as he returned it to me. "It's safe."  

Tenure exists so you and I will never have to read a "safe" book. We should have this guarantee that any work of original scholarship - whether we believe it gets it wrong or right, whether it leads to a real breakthrough or a dead end - gives you an author's best judgment, unsafe as that may be.  

That's why tenure matters.

 

7 comments

Leave a comment
  1. Al | Nov 27, 2016
  2. umam asa | Nov 20, 2016
    listrik dan panas, serta mempunyai titik cair tinggi. Bijih logam ditemukan dengan cara  penambangan yang terdapat dalam keadaan murni atau bercampur dengan unsur-unsur seperti karbon, sulfur, fosfor, silikon, serta kotoran seperti tanah liat, pasir, dan tanah. ditributor besi beton ditributor besi beton ditributor besi beton ais ditributor besi beton ais ditributor besi beton Sni Ulir Polos ditributor besi beton Sni Ulir Polos ditributor besi beton bjku ditributor besi beton bjku ditributor besi beton cakra steel cs ditributor besi beton cakra steel cs ditributor besi beton delcoprima ditributor besi beton delcoprima ditributor besi beton gunung garuda ditributor besi beton gunung garuda ditributor besi beton interworld steel is ditributor besi beton interworld steel is ditributor besi beton jcac ditributor besi beton jcac ditributor besi beton krakatau steel ditributor besi beton krakatau steel ditributor besi beton ksty ditributor besi beton ksty ditributor besi beton master steel ms ditributor besi beton master steel ms ditributor besi beton PAS ditributor besi beton PAS ditributor besi beton perwira ditributor besi beton perwira ditributor besi beton psi Ulir Polos ditributor besi beton psi Ulir Polos ditributor besi beton sii ditributor besi beton sii ditributor besi beton Sni Ulir Polos polos ulir ditributor besi beton Sni Ulir Polos polos ulir www.ditributorbesibajamurah.com www.ditributorbesibajamurah.com www.pusatbesibaja.com www.pusatbesibaja.com www.pusatbesibaja.co.id www.pusatbesibaja.co.id jasa konstruksi baja jasa konstruksi baja undangan pernikahan undangan pernikahan jasa konstruksi jual laptop asus jasa konstruksi baja jasa konstruksi baja wf jasa konstruksi gudang jasa konstruksi jembatan jasa konstruksi gedung jasa konstruksi bangunan www.husnialbardani.com www.husnialbardani.com ditributor laptop asus murah ditributor laptop asus murah     www.sentrabesibaja.com Daftar ditributor Besi Hollow Dari ditributor Pabrik ditributor Besi Beton Daftar ditributor Besi Pipa Baja Schedule 40 Dari ditributor Pabrik ditributor Besi H beam Daftar ditributor Besi H beam Yang Diditributor Dari Pabrik Ke Agen ditributor Besi Wf Info ditributor Welded Beam T beam King Queen Cross Castellated Beam ditributor Pipa Besi Hitam Medium Daftar ditributor Bondek Cor Ter Murah ditributor Pabrik ditributor Besi Pipa Baja Schedule 40 sentra besi baja ditributor Besi Pipa Baja Schedule 80 Daftar ditributor Besi Unp Baja Profil Kanal ditributor Pabrik ditributor Wiremesh Daftar ditributor Besi Pipa Baja Schedule 80 Dari ditributor Pabrik ditributor Besi Hollow Daftar ditributor Plat Kapal Dari Pabrik Ke ditributor ditributor Besi Cnp Profil Baja Gording Daftar ditributor Atap Spandek Sni Dari Supplier Pabrik ditributor Besi Unp Baja Profil Kanal Daftar ditributor Plat Besi Hitam Dari Supplier Pabrik ditributor ditributor Besi Siku Baja Daftar ditributor ditributor Besi Siku Baja Dari Supplier Pabrik ditributor Plat Kapal Bki Krakatau Steel Daftar ditributor Pipa Besi Hitam Medium Dari Agen Pabrik ditributor Plat Besi Hitam Daftar ditributor Wiremesh Yang Diditributor Dari Pabrik Ke Supplier ditributor Plat Bordes Kembang Daftar ditributor Besi Wf Diditributor Dari Pabrik Lewat Supplier ditributor Atap Spandek Sni Daftar ditributor Plat Bordes Kembang Dari ditributor Pabrik ditributor Bondek Cor Daftar ditributor Besi Beton Yang Di ditributor Dari Pabrik Ke ditributor ditributor Welded Beam T beam King Queen Cross Castellated Beam Daftar ditributor Besi Cnp Profil Baja Gording Supplier Pabrik jasa konstruksi jual laptop asus jasa konstruksi baja jasa konstruksi baja wf jasa konstruksi gudang jasa konstruksi jembatan jasa konstruksi gedung jasa konstruksi bangunan www.husnialbardani.com www.husnialbardani.com www.mrosidin.com www.cerahcollection.com jual laptop asus murah jual laptop asus murah
  3. lzm | Nov 19, 2016

    ugg boots outlet

    ralph lauren shirts

    nike jordan shoes

    sunglasses outlet

    michael kors outlet

    MCM Outlet

    abercrombie outlet

    Nike Jordans

    ray-ban sunglasses

    kate spade purses outlet

    nike basketball shoes

    ralph lauren

    Nike Free

    timberland uk

    oakley sunglasses

    michael kors outlet

    nike huarache

    wholesale

    Yeezy Boost 350

    michael kors black friday

    ugg boots

    moncler us

    Prada bags

    Hermes Outlet

    ugg uk

    top sunglasses

    kate spade outlet

    coach outlet,coach factory

    coach outlet online

    kate spade bags

    oakley outlet

    pandora jewelry

    pandora rings jewelry

    pandora charms

    kate spade outlet

    abercrombie outlet

    mlb shop

    true religion

    michael kors

    longchamp outlet

    pandora uk

    michael kors wallet

    Longchamp Outlet

    snow boots

    prada bags

    burberry scarfs

    china factory sale

    Nike Air Jordan

    cheap basketball shoes

    coach sunglasses for women

    kate spade purses

    Ralph Lauren UK

    michael kors outlet

    burberry outlet

    canada goose jacket

    coach outlet

    kate spade UK

    coach bags

    michael kors outlet

    abssice 360

    michael kors italy

    kate spade

    nike shox

    kate spade outlet online

    nike air huarache

    salomon shoes

    Jordan Retro Shoes

    michael kors tote

    Chanel Outlet

    christian louboutin online

    moncler jacket

    michael kors tote bags

    kate spade outlet

    longchamp sac

    R.B Sunglasses

    prada outlet online

    prada outlet online

    KD 8 shoes

    Polo Ralph Lauren

    pandora rings

    moncler uk

    moncler outlet

    pandora bracelet

    ralph lauren uk

    oakley frogskins

    ray ban prescription glasses

    sunglasses sm

    sheepskin boots on sale

    Michael Kors Watches

    Pandora Charm

    louboutin shoes

    coach bag

    veronique billat

    michael kors outlet

    yeezy shoes adidas

    coach sunglasses

    Jordan Retro

    kate spade bags outlet

    coach outlet online

    coach australia

    pandora rings

    michael kors outlet

    michael kors purses

    Canada Goose Outlet

    nike australia

    moncler outlet

    prada bags

    michael kors outlet bags

    hermes birkin price

    ugg australia

    Michael Kors Canada

    burberry scarf

    kate spade

    prada handbags

    burberry outlet online

    michael kors outlet

    cheap moncler jacket

    sac longchamp

    clk benz

    louboutin heels

    Coach outlet online

    MIZUNO Shop US

    burberry outlet

    michael kors outlet online

    pandora rings

    michael kors

    michael kors outlet

    beats by dre

    coach outlet

    prada online

    Nike Lebron Shoes

    jimmy choo australia

    abercrombie us

    michael kors totes

    sunglasses hut

    true religion uk

    sheepskin boots

    balenciaga us

    hermes bag

    prada outlet

    Ralph Lauren

    kate spade

    longchamps

    Longchamp Bags

    kate spade black friday

    salomon hiking shoes

    Coach Sunglasses Outlet

    oakley australia

    michael kors purses outlet

    burberry online

    pandora necklace

    nike shoes

    pandora.com

    nike outlet

    kate spade outlet

    michael kors jet set tote

    baseball jerseys

    kate spade outlet online

    ray ban wayfarer

    yeezy boost 350 shoes

    coach outlet

    abercrombie us

    jordan shoes

    Nike Hyperdunk 2015

    brand sunglasses

    mlb shop

    Lebron 13

    asics gel

    pandora rings sale

    nike id

    Mizuno Wave

    coach handbags

    coach australia

    ralph lauren

    pandora bracelets

    michael kors outlet

    Burberry Factory Outlet

    change points uk

    tiffany co

    shoes sale

    ralph lauren uk

    coach outlet online

    Hugo Boss Store

    kate spade bags

    coach diaper bag

    kate spade outlet

    prada official site

    official prada site

    pandora uk

    michael kors outlet

    michael kors tote

    abercrombie and fitch

    prada tote

    yeezy boost 350

    beats headphones

    burberry outlet

    Pandora bracelet

    pandora princess ring

    prada bag

    ugg boots sale

    nike shoes

    major league baseball

    michael kors

    burberry outlet online

    true religion jeans

    prada outlet online

    Nike KD 8

    B Derbyshire

    nike store

    moncler mens jackets

    louboutin shoes

    michael kors bags

    nike australia

    michael kors outlet

    michael kors handbags outlet

    michael kors bags outlet

    air jordan shoes

    mk outlet

    kate spade canada

    burberry outlet online

    michael kors outlet

    ray ban prescription sunglasses

    pandora ring

    ralph lauren australia

    hermes uk

    ugg slippers

    Prada Shopper Tote

    flash sunglasses

    abercrombie and fitch

    Kate Spade Australia

    coach outlet store

    Burberry outlet online

    asics Australia

    christian louboutin shoes

    prada glasses

    coach purse

    Nike Jordan Shoes

    coach outlet

    Ralph Lauren Polo

    burberry australia

    jordan retro shoes

    air jordan shoes

    michael kors bags

    canada goose jacket

    coach shoes

    ugg boots uk

    nike store

    burberry outlet

    balenciaga bag

    moncler coats

    michael kors outlet

    landing gears

    Ralph Lauren Polo

    michael kors outlet

    Cheap Ray Ban

    moncler clothing

    huarache nike

    nike lebron shoes

    ray ban online

    nfl jerseys

    burberry outlet canada

    asics shoes

    Chanel Tote Bag 2015

    ray ban glasses

    yeezy shoes

    michael kors outlet

    pandora australia

    pandora charms

    burberry online

    coach factory outlet

    prada sunglasses

    abercrombie outlet

    Prada Factory Outlet

    pandora rings

    mk bags

    true religion uk

    oakley sunglasses

    ugg boots uk

    mlb.com

    canada goose sale online

    burberry

    ray ban new wayfarer

    Michael Kors Outlet

    nike shoes

    coach outlet

    Bed and Breakfast in chesterfield

    Nike Air Jordan

    hermes birkin

    michael kors outlet

    cheap ray ban sunglasses

    air yeezy shoes

    michael kors purses on sale

    pandora bracelet

    michael kors outlet

    polo online

    china wholesale

    Oakley Outlet

    Kobe X Shoes

    michael kors outlet

    pandora necklace charms

    chanel tote bag

    canada goose outlet

    coach outlet online

    coach outlet

    coach carter

    nike huarache shoes

    moncler down jackets

    pandora charms

    michael kors

    michael kors outlet

    coach outlet

    ray ban eyeglasses

    burberry outlet

    rayban aviator

    nike shoes australia

    burberry canada

    asics gel kayano

    michael kors outlet

    coach australia

    landinggear

    mens sunglasses

    pandora bracelet

    paul smith

    kate spade outlet

    moncler jacket

    burberry us

    tiffany co

    abercrombie & fitch

    ray ban clubmaster

    hermes uk

    coach online

    prada handbags

    air jordan retro

    coach factory

    burberry outlets

    pandora rings

    prada outlet

    longchamp outlet

    kate spade outlet

    coach online

    ray-ban sunglasses

    moncler outlet

    hermes purses

    michael kors factory outlet

    coach factory outlet

    bercrombie Nederland

    ugg boots

    michael kors australia

    mk handbags

    official prada site

    burberry scarf

    pandora rings

    ugg boots

    prada outlet

    burberry outlet

    ray ban sunglasses

    abercrombie outlet us

    chanel tote

    coach outlet online

    michael kors outlet

    longchamp bag

    Burberry online

    ugg slippers

    pandora jewelry

    polo outlet online

    shoes online

    coach

    michael kors handbags

    pandora australia

    Nike Air Max

    huaraches

    michael kors online

    Mizuno Shop Japan

    uggs outlet

    pirate system

    michael kors canada

    prada tote bag

    ray ban polarized

    kate spade

    coach factory outlet

    Burberry Outlet

    burberry purse

    Nike Kobe 9

    nike com

    ugg uk

    longchamp backpack

    abercrombie paris

    michael kors australia

    burberry outlet canada

    abercrombie and fitch

    yeezy boost 350

    michael kors outlet online

    kate spade handbags

    coach bags

    nike jordan shoes

    pandora uk

    Abercrombie Fitch

    michael kors uk

    Whitton Lodge Chesterfield Derbyshire UK

    burberry online

    prada us

    burberry outlet

    Coach Outlet Online

    Oakley Holbrook

    shoes online sale

    asics shoes Australia

    pandora australia

    burberry canada

    prada bags on sale

    sheepskin boots for women

    michael kors outlet

    coach outlet online

    longchamp backpack

    pandora necklaces

    Hugo Boss Online

    piumini moncler replica

    huaraches shoes

    coach handbags

    prada purses

    Hyperdunk 2016

    nike lebron james

    abercrombie outlet

    burberry outlet

    coach usa

    nike free run

    coach outlet

    Michael Kors Watches Outlet

    Nike Hyperdunk Shoes

    CHanel Factory Outlet

    Prada Outlet

    Chanel bags Outlet

    Coach Outlet Store

    michael kors outlet

    official michael kors

    beats studio

    prada handbags

    chanel bag

    burberry

    chanel australia

    michael kors outlet

    Official Ralph Lauren UK Online Store

    pandora australia

    Nike Lebron 12

    Kobe 9 Shoes

    michael kors outlet online

    Hugo Boss Outlet

    asics kayano

    oakley frogskins sunglasses

    burberry outlet

    abercrombie fitch

    kate spade black friday

    ate spade handbags

    lebron james shoes

    polo outlet

    Adidas Yeezy Boost 350

    ugg australia

    michael kors us

    nike shox shoes

    Coach Outlet

    balenciaga bags

    canada goose sale

    moncler jacket mens

    paul smith sale

    adidas yeezy boost 350

    coach factory outlet online

    michael kors handbags

    coach factory outlet

    nike jordan shoes

    coach outlet

    Michael Kors Outlet

    Polo Ralph Lauren

    sunglasses hut

    nfl shop

    moncler sale

    nike air max

    Mizuno Shop

    michael kors outlet

    timberland boots

    Michael Kors Watches Online

    coach outlet

    prada bags

    paul smith uk

    ray-ban sunglasses

    pandora charms sale

    chanel

    Billat

    longchamp sale

    burberry outlet

    oakley sunglasses

    ray ban sunglasses

    nike outlet

    Free Run

    pandora charms

    Oakley Holbrook sunglasses

    nike shoes

    Kevin Durant Shoes

    cheap coach purse

    Mizuno Shoes

    Jordan retro

    burberry australia

    nike outlet

    Ray Ban Outlet

    ray ban aviator

    burberry scarf

    michael kors bags

    michael kors outlet

    pandora charms uk

    moncler jacket

    pandora jewelry

    véronique Billat

    abercrombie outlet

    nike jordan

    michael kors outlet store

    coach purses

    michael kors purses

    michael kors outlet

    michael kors handbags

    Basketball shoes

    Yeezy 350

    michael kors

    landing gear

    Mizuno Running Shoes

    mlb store

  4. umam asa | Oct 27, 2016
    undangan pernikahan islami undangan pernikahan islami undangan pernikahan undangan pernikahan islami undangan pernikahan islami undangan pernikahan elegan undangan pernikahan elegan undangan pernikahan undangan pernikahan elegan undangan pernikahan elegan
  5. umam asa | Oct 27, 2016
  6. umam asa | Oct 27, 2016
    jasa konstruksi jasa pembuatan konstruksi billboard jasa konstruksi bangunan i http://www.fabrikasikonstruksi.com/ jasa konstruksi baja ringan jasa konstruksi jasa konstruksi baja ringan jasa konstruksi i http://www.fabrikasikonstruksi.com/ jasa konstruksi baja bangun pabrik
  7. anonym | Oct 24, 2016
    Super website with a great sharing and amazing stories is ur web.. please keep doing what u do now.. thanks to you. Agen Bandarq
    Agen domino
    Domino Online
    agen Bandarq
    Bandar domino99  agen domino online    berita politik berita politik terkini

    Leave a comment

    • 1044 Alta Vista Road |
    • Louisville, KY 40205 |
    • 800.264.1839 |
    • Fax: 502.895.1096 |
    • Site Map
    © Louisville Presbyterian Theological Seminary