• Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Flickr
  • YouTube
Thinking Out Loud

"Unwinding": the Power and Limitations of Story

by Michael Jinkins | Jun 18, 2013

In his remarkable new book, The Unwinding: An Inner History of the New America, (New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2013), George Packer sets out to describe "the vertigo of that unwinding" which has affected virtually every aspect of American life since the 1960s. "You watched structures that had been in place before your birth collapse like pillars of salt across the vast visible landscape - the farms of the Carolina Piedmont, the factories of the Mahoning Valley, Florida subdivisions, California schools. And other things, harder to see but no less vital in supporting the order of everyday life, changed beyond recognition - ways and means in Washington caucus rooms, taboos on New York trading desks, manners and morals everywhere." Packer, looking back over the past couple of generations, writes in the book's prologue, "The norms that made the old institutions useful began to unwind, and the leaders abandoned their posts." (3) 

I rushed to our local bookstore to get a copy of the book, hoping it might illuminate the erosion of trust and confidence in the institutions of our age, a phenomenon which, incidentally, is not limited to the United States. The immediate reason I wanted to read the book was in preparation for a trans-Atlantic consultation in which Debbie and I have been invited to participate later this month at Windsor Castle outside of London. A group of about twenty scholars, institutional leaders and politicians, mostly, but not exclusively, from Britain will discuss and debate the future and well-being of institutions. The consultation is jointly sponsored by St. George's House, Windsor, and The Center of Theological Inquiry, Princeton. I hoped that Packer's book might provide fresh insights and analyses which would benefit our discussion.  

Packer's method for getting at the truth is to tell stories of Americans living through this age along with us. He tells these stories patiently, allowing the details to accumulate in layers. The story of Jeff Connaughton, a Democratic operative, is told alongside the story of Republican leader Newt Gingrich. The story of Tammy Thomas, an African-American woman working hard and often against seemingly insurmountable forces, in Youngstown, Ohio, trying just to keep body and soul and family together, is told next door to the triumphant story of Oprah, a black woman of such world-renown and stature that she needs only a single name to identify her. Writer Raymond Carver, General Colin Powell and financial giant Robert Rubin are profiled beside failed entrepreneurs and working class heroes, idealists and pragmatists.  

Packer's narratives are thick and rich; and insights and reflections do surface in the midst of the stories.  

For example, Dean Price, the struggling owner of service stations and fast food restaurants, reflects on the impact of "big box" stores that wipe out small local businesses: "And if you think about it," Price says, "the people that ran the hardware store, the shoe store, the little restaurant that was here, they were the fabric of the community, They were the leaders. They were the Little League baseball coaches, they were the town council members, they were the people everybody looked up to. We lost that." (145) 

Or, in one aside, Packer himself considers the power of diversity in a flesh and blood community: "Life is richest and most creative," he writes, "where people of different backgrounds could meet face-to-face and exchange ideas." (197) 

Startling facts emerge from the densely packed stories.  

For instance, I learned that six surviving members of Sam Walton's family (Mr. Sam was the founder of the Walmart empire) "have as much money as the bottom thirty percent of Americans." (104) And the profiles of places like Silicon Valley and Tampa and Wall Street are fascinating.  

But, in the final analysis, in the wake of reading this delightful book, the feeling was unavoidable that Packer illustrates a situation without really illuminating it. In some ways, he demonstrates the power of stories to move us emotionally, but there are limitations when it comes to making sense of vast social forces.  

What Packer does, however, is very important in itself. Recently, as we have read the latest data on the rise of religiously non-affiliated people, and even more recently reading the latest statistics related to the continuing decline among Presbyterians, it is tempting to focus on "what's wrong with Protestantism?" or "What's wrong with MY brand of Protestantism?"  

Someone recently in a Q&A session in the Midwest, after I had made a presentation on the importance of a thinking faith, asked me: "But isn't this why Presbyterians are declining? Because we value thinking so much?" "No," I responded, "Even unthinking Protestantism is declining."

But, here's the point that Packer makes eloquently: institutions and social forms and professions and ways of life of all sorts are suffering profound and apparently irremediable losses. A poet might say that we live in a time when the centers no longer hold. The illustration of this fact is powerful.

What I wish Packer helped with more is analysis, the careful, critical, systematic reflection that might help us understand "why?" and "how can we address the situation?" Ironically, we need more of the theoretical, i.e., the construction of viable models to help us comprehend what it is happening.  

Some things are clear. Many people seem to have lost confidence in the structures that previously gave meaning to and provided the organizing principles for social life, whether civic, educational or religious, political, legal or moral, and which communicated core values from one generation to another. And, correspondingly, many people seem to have lost trust in the leaders who populated those structures. As recent studies (such as those conducted by Pew) have shown, even the most intimate "institutions" such as the formal, socially sanctioned union of persons in marriage, have steadily suffered erosion. Distrust of larger institutions and of the people who lead them is rife.  

This is not to say, however, that people are necessarily less caring or responsive today. In fact, we are also witnessing the burgeoning of a variety of forms of loose affiliations of people - both web-based and face-to-face - banding together to make all sorts of differences. These affiliations blossom and wither, appear and disappear quickly, many of the persons who respond overlapping, meeting one and another need or responding to this or that social issue, then dispersing. I suspect we are witnessing even now the writing of the next chapter of human institutional history. It is not all bad news, but there are real losses as Packer chronicles.  

Tellingly, at the very opening of Packer's book, he says that, "The unwinding" which we are witnessing today "is nothing new. There have been unwindings every generation or two." I think it is crucial to keep this perspective. I also think it is important to look afresh at some of the better sociological and political analyses that have emerged in recent years (I'm thinking for example of Hugh Heclo's brilliant study, "On Thinking Institutionally" (Paradigm, 2008)), to understand more deeply the social experiences Packer illustrates.  

Illustration is valuable, but illumination leads to action.  

Editor’s note: this will be Michael’s final post before taking his summer break from Thinking Out Loud. In his absence, we are fortunate to have several guest bloggers who have accepted the invitation to write for the blog. Michael is deeply grateful for these people and for their willingness to share their insights with us during the summer months. Look for posts by students Abbi Long and Abbie Trowbridge, Director of Clinical Training for the Seminary’s Counseling Center Jenny Schiller, Seminary Trustee Morgan Roberts, Dean Sue Garrett, Assistant Professor of Old Testament/Hebrew Bible Tyler Mayfield and others!



59 comments

Leave a comment
  1. Robinjack | Jan 14, 2017
    This is exceptionally instructive substance and composed well for a change. It's pleasant to see that a few individuals still see how to compose a quality post!  His Secret Obsession
  2. GinnaKelly | Jan 12, 2017
  3. wasdasd | Jan 11, 2017
    I adore this online journal!! The blaze up the top is wonderful!!  vector logo design service
  4. Best WhatsApp Status | Jan 11, 2017
    Thanks for such post.For Best WhatsApp Status just visit Attitude WhatsApp Status
  5. Best WhatsApp Status | Jan 11, 2017
    Thanks for such post.For Best WhatsApp Status just visit <a href="http://www.statusbest.com">Best WhatsApp Status</a>
  6. GinnaKelly | Jan 10, 2017
  7. GinnaKelly | Jan 08, 2017
  8. GinnaKelly | Jan 07, 2017
  9. GinnaKelly | Jan 06, 2017
  10. GinnaKelly | Jan 05, 2017
  11. Deanna | Jan 05, 2017

    This is really a nice and informative, containing all information and also has a great impact. Thanks for sharing it,

    best solar panel supplier

  12. GinnaKelly | Jan 03, 2017
  13. Ginn kell | Dec 31, 2016
  14. jasawebb.com | Dec 30, 2016
    You’ve written nice post, I am gonna bookmark this page, thanks for info. I actually appreciate your own position and I will be sure to come back here.his is a really good post. Must admit that you are among the best bloggers I have read. Thanks for posting this informative article of cara menggugurkan kandungan. You may havce a lot of jual obat aborsi and obat aborsi
    I was reading the provided article with a great interest! This post is useful and informative cara menggugurkan kandungan.Thanks for sharing obat telat datang bulan and also obat telat bulan. You’ve written nice post, I am gonna bookmark this page, thanks for obat telat datang bulan info. I actually appreciate your own position and I will be sure to come back here.his is a really good post. Good post. I learn something new and challenging on jasa website blogs I stumbleupon every day.It will always be exciting to read content from other writers and use a  jual obat aborsi and obat aborsi little something from their jasa pembuatan website
    I would once again praise to god about this amazing post. Thank you so much for the detailed information. I love to read tips from cara menggugurkan kandungan who are really successful with what they do. It inspires me an I learn a lot witch helps me to grow my business obat penggugur kandungan faster.Well, Thanks a lot for such a wonderful post of obat aborsi, the stuff posted were really interesting and useful jual obat aborsi. The quality of the content was good and clear.
  15. Ginnkell | Dec 19, 2016
  16. BandarQ | Dec 18, 2016
  17. Dewa poker | Dec 18, 2016
  18. Jangkrik | Dec 15, 2016
  19. Ginakell | Dec 14, 2016
  20. YOYO | Dec 14, 2016
  21. Ginkell | Dec 12, 2016
  22. bandar kiu | Dec 08, 2016

    Thank your site! information your share is useful to me!

    Bandarceme

    Bandar Kiu


  23. Ginkell | Dec 07, 2016
  24. bella | Dec 07, 2016
  25. walsh | Dec 07, 2016
  26. Jangkrik | Dec 06, 2016
  27. Ginnkell | Dec 02, 2016
  28. hunt | Dec 02, 2016
  29. Charlesdan | Dec 02, 2016
    thank  you for sharing nice story with us.  kik login
  30. Charles | Nov 28, 2016

      Very interesting blog. A lot of blogs I see these days don't really provide anything that I'm interested in, but I'm most definitely interested in this one. nice thanks for share great post here.Teamsnap log in | chinagrabber

  31. GinnKell | Nov 24, 2016
  32. silvia vero | Nov 20, 2016
  33. GinnaKelly | Nov 18, 2016
  34. supersmashflash2 | Nov 18, 2016
    bloonstowerdefense5web  bloonstowerdefense-1 bloonstowerdefense bloonstowerdefense5    bloons tower defense 5 paulpowellhd bloonstowerdefense bloonstowerdefense         BloonsTowerDefense5     This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. :) :) towerdefense    108514638062834466961  bloonstowerdefense 189727360 paulpowellhd paulpowellc1c5   towerdefense bloonstowerdefense bloonstowerdefense5web supersmashflash2web    supersmashflash2-1 rebeccahickshq                                       supersmashflash2 supersmashflash02                                       supersmashflash2    supersmashflash2                                supersmashflash2                                   rebeccahickshq supersmashflash2                                   super smash flash 2 lerma   supersmashflash supersmashflash2 super smash flash 2 supersmashflash02 rebeccahickshq rebeccahicb62c supersmashflash2-1 supersmashflash2
  35. bella hunt | Nov 18, 2016

    this is really nice...well done..!!

    whatsapp status

     
  36. BandarPoker | Nov 17, 2016
  37. aily | Nov 17, 2016
    great points being  explained  above!!! thx for posting a important blog Spotify free
  38. rianda mimi | Nov 17, 2016
  39. Jangkrik | Nov 16, 2016
  40. Bandar Asia99 | Nov 15, 2016
  41. Jangkrik | Nov 13, 2016
  42. Ajay singh | Nov 09, 2016
    Goo story shared. Stories gives us an opportunity to go through the experiences people have in their day to day lives.I can not thank you enough for items on your website. I know you put a lot of time and energy on these and hope he knows how much I enjoy it. I hope I'll make the man or woman identical at some point.  Exchange 1000 rs note  | Replace your old currency
  43. B | Nov 06, 2016
  44. Ginna Kelly | Nov 06, 2016

    AMAZING POST..

    bandarq

    bandar domino

    agen poker

    THANKFULLY..

  45. rangga | Nov 05, 2016
  46. Megilvy | Nov 04, 2016

    Nice guidelines described in this blog.Thanks.

    seo services company india

  47. Ravi | Oct 30, 2016

    Best Power Banks India

    I think I could probably eat this for dessert! I have never eaten sweet potatoes like this although I have done a similar thing with carrots and loved it.

  48. Ginna Kelly | Oct 30, 2016
  49. anonym | Oct 24, 2016
    Super website with a great sharing and amazing stories is ur web.. please keep doing what u do now.. thanks to you. Agen Bandarq
    Agen domino
    Domino Online
    agen Bandarq
    Bandar domino99  agen domino online    berita politik berita politik terkini
  50. Charles Dan | Oct 20, 2016
      I had to rush to market to buy this amazing book :The Unwinding: An Inner History of the New America, because i didnot find it online shops. This is full of enthusiasm, In this book, all the stories from the ancient time of America to the modern america are very well explained. Thanks for sharing this information here on this website. i got to know about his this from your article.  Are you in trouble while using your debit cards provided by the banks and thinking about the security. Use hassle free online/offline payments use Netspend debit cards. Step by step guide to Netspend. Netspend signin Netspend webmail login

    Leave a comment

    • 1044 Alta Vista Road |
    • Louisville, KY 40205 |
    • 800.264.1839 |
    • Fax: 502.895.1096 |
    • Site Map
    © Louisville Presbyterian Theological Seminary