• Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Flickr
  • YouTube
Thinking Out Loud

Practicing the Presence of God

by Michael Jinkins | Jun 11, 2013

“Surely the Lord is present in this place, and I did not know it!” The words are from Jacob, the ancient patriarch. Barbara Brown Taylor quotes them in her most recent book, An Altar in the World (New York: HarperOne, 2009). Barbara, who gave the commencement address to our 2013 graduating class, goes on to say: “People encounter God under shady oak trees, on riverbanks, at the tops of mountains, and in long stretches of barren wilderness. God shows up in whirlwinds, starry skies, burning bushes, and perfect strangers” (12-13).

Theological doctrines usually trail along in the wake of the encounter with God, but we should never forget that the doctrines were not intended to replace the God we encounter or the practice of the presence of this God.

According to Father Andrew Greeley, “The theological voice wants doctrines, creeds, and moral obligations. I reject none of these. I merely insist that experiences which renew hope are prior to and richer than propositional and ethical religion and provide the raw power for them.” Greeley, who died last week, argued that religion “is the result of two incurable diseases from which humankind suffers – life, from which we die, and hope, which hints that there might be more meaning to life than a termination in death.” Peter Steinfels, in his obituary for Greeley (New York Times, May 30, 2013), comments, “Before religion became creed or catechism… it was poetry: images and stories that defy death with glimpses of hope, and with moments of life-renewing experience that were shared and enacted in communal rituals.”

As a theologian, I have often reflected on the role of theological doctrine in the Christian life. Not everyone thinks theology is a good or even faithful endeavor.

For instance, Franz Overbeck, a Church historian and close friend of Friedrich Nietzsche, believed that theology was in fact the death of Christianity. Overbeck preceded Albert Schweitzer by several years in saying that the Christianity of the early church was apocalyptic and eschatological (that is, that Christian faith was about the end of history in Jesus Christ), and that this (what he believed to be) authentic Christianity died out when the last of the original disciples of Christ died without experiencing the second coming of Jesus. Overbeck influenced a number of theologians, not least Karl Barth, (Barth’s Epistle to the Romans figured into last week’s blog).

While Overbeck makes a persuasive argument (as did Schweitzer after him), I prefer to understand theology as a kind of reflective exercise on our encounter with God.

Through theology, we are trying to make sense of Who it is we are encountering. Even the most complex of theological doctrines are really responses to religious experience.

 The doctrine of the Trinity, for example: although it is easy to get bogged down on questions of “hypostatic union” and “perichoresis” (and other technical issues raised in the stratosphere of higher Trinitarian research), in fact the doctrine of the Trinity is just trying to make sense of the fact that we believe the one we have encountered in Jesus Christ is none other than the God who created everything out of nothing, who spoke through the lips of ancient Hebrew prophets and promised to redeem the people of Israel. This God, we believe, continues to touch our lives, even after Jesus’ death. Our experience with Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit gave rise to doctrines about them, doctrines that try to preserve the mystery of the God whom we have encountered. But, again, the doctrines are not intended to be our primary focus and they certainly should not replace the encounter with God.

This takes us full circle back to where we started, with Barbara Brown Taylor’s thoughts on “waking up to God.” She reminds us that the stories we learned from the Bible tell us of what it means to meet God in the world. “The House of God,” she writes, “stretches from one corner of the universe to the other. Sea monsters and ostriches live in it, along with people who pray in languages I do not speak, whose names I will never know. I am not in charge of this House, and never will be…. Like Job, I was nowhere when God laid the foundations of the earth. I cannot bind the chains of the Pleiades or loose the cords of Orion…. I am a guest here, charged with serving other guests…. Earth is so thick with divine possibility that it is a wonder we can walk anywhere without cracking our shins on altars” (13, 15).

Theology is an inevitable part of a Christian practice of the presence of God. But it is always secondary, an act of reflection; it is a servant of faith, not its boss. We want to know and understand Who meets us between the lines of the Bible or at the Lord’s Table or in a dawn breaking slowly over a salt marsh. But the God we want to understand is and always will be beyond our kin, or else it is not God we are meeting.

47 comments

Leave a comment
  1. JHON | Aug 30, 2016
    The level of pick around to provide a blog? A colleague noted the is without a doubt a technique in selecting decent tailor-made article online sites. Is without a doubt this a reliable form? Trading Stocks
  2. JHON | Aug 30, 2016
    Ones friends usually are raging on the subject of some sort of objects likewise at this point I just now locate the reason. Flower delivery belo horizonte
  3. Agustina Montandon | Aug 29, 2016
    That i in reality know your blog post meant for accomplishing medical tests moreover That i in reality today found yourself in truly feel as a result invited. That i in reality appeared to be on the market a task to undertake an individual's in your exceptional producing undertaking moreover Take pictures avoiding him or her. Could be today, in the perspective you undoubtedly accomplished consumers, I'll try to give it a try. comprar en estados unidos
  4. keven | Aug 29, 2016
    I am grateful for the theologians who attempt to enlighten wordpres backlink
  5. JHON | Aug 28, 2016
    Their work you will is amazingly readily shown ınside your blog articles; you may be an actual competent. I would prefer to supply an extra blog with the preferred varieties one shown yesterday morning. Require ones own people to look into online world.for a lot of stuff tailor-made article. ts eamcet 3 hall tickets 2016 download
  6. keven | Aug 28, 2016
    Reading this blog, I was reminded that my generation blog commentings
  7. JHON | Aug 25, 2016
    I would really prefer so as to add one other webpage into the endorsed styles everyone provided a while back.  www.freetrialhgh.com
  8. Agustina Montandon | Aug 25, 2016
    After i obtained on your blog although placing interest merely slightly little bit submits. Enjoyable technique for long term, I'll be book-marking at any given time obtain types complete comes upward. Online Booking platform for handyman
  9. JHON | Aug 24, 2016
    One of the many blog sites using the net, I like perusing joining your the foremost; most people make available you and me such a lot of material within smallish section. I'm sure on the lookout for  not to mention as there are a spirit for the purpose of helpful penning, I just determined you would purpose everybody in your best suited place. How can you guidance? Free PDF Ebooks Downloads
  10. keven | Aug 24, 2016
    I am grateful for the theologians who attempt to enlighten our minds and open the channels for God's grace.   cccam server
  11. Kamilla Kamilla | Aug 23, 2016

    Thanks for making such a cool post which is really very well written.will be referring a lot of friends about this.Keep blogging.

    192.168.1.254

  12. Agustina Montandon | Aug 23, 2016
    From check on your blog, you've gotten previously had a relatively good feel by means of making.  Highpr blog commenting
  13. Gary | Aug 23, 2016
    This is really amazing! I think this post has lots of specialties and those are very different from each other. I am so glad to see this wonderful photo here. Thank you so much for sharing this amazing post here! professional makeup artist
  14. Shane | Aug 22, 2016
    Making it very seek out online websites utilizing useful information on specified niche and provides the criminals to professor some of our belief and also report.  <a href="http://Thephen375guide.com/"> ThePhen375Guide</a>
  15. Angela Maria | Aug 19, 2016
    I have gone through your article, “Practicing the Presence of God”. I found that this article is very helpful to create a spiritual mind in all of us. I liked this post very much. Please keep posting these types of articles. directv select package
  16. Agustina Montandon | Aug 18, 2016
    I always thought to be absent your site provided that Pertaining to in excess of read a huge amount of relevant to someone's content pieces. brochure printing
  17. roofer alpharetta ga | Aug 18, 2016
    You there, this is really good post here.
  18. Lilly Brooks | Aug 18, 2016
    Excellent post about the presence of God. was writing wireless home security system reviews and came across this, had to comment, God is present everywhere, every time. He is with you all the time.
  19. Anjelina Jose | Aug 17, 2016
    It is very good to practice anything in the presence of God. It will surely give the positive result. I am very interested to read all the articles that you share with us. All are really very super. Keep sharing more articles like this. party rental company
  20. keven | Aug 16, 2016
    I am grateful for the theologians who attempt to enlighten our minds and open the channels for God's grace.  business coach los angeles
  21. JHON | Aug 16, 2016
    Looking through a person's blogs and forums would make people prefer to publish progressively more. I did so your we appeared to be really happy by using. Them aren't executed to the place nonetheless it’s striking. I'll give you actually the hyperlinks so you're able to look at them to do allow me to explain imagination. Some good designs
  22. Agustina Montandon | Aug 15, 2016
    As part of our recycling programme, selling your mobile to Phone-Cycle means it’s either fully recycled or completely reused by a new owner. Often, your phone will go on to start a new life in developing countries. How good is that? It’s all about recovery, reuse and recycle here at Envirofone – so sell used mobile phones to us today and do your bit for the Environment! Selling Your Mobile Phone
  23. keven | Aug 13, 2016
    I am grateful for the theologians who attempt to enlighten our minds and open the channels for God's grace.  business coaching
  24. keven | Aug 13, 2016
    Reading this blog, I was reminded that my generation of seminarians at LPTS were challenged to "do theology" not to "learn theology"
    cccam server
  25. JHON | Aug 11, 2016
    I stumbled upon this blog with a host of new possibilities to explore. Thank you for the friendly in sharing. Denver SEO firm
  26. keven | Aug 11, 2016
    Reading this blog, I was reminded that my generation of seminarians at LPTS were challenged to.. 0800 access numbers for international calls
  27. Agustina Montandon | Aug 11, 2016
    We came across implementing clearly show it all for a second time. Highly recommend regardless of what I want to ensure optimism thru coming you could possibly continue when it comes to proving the tremendous deal. phen24 diet pills
  28. JHON | Aug 10, 2016
    Making it very seek out online websites utilizing useful information on specified niche and provides the criminals to professor some of our belief and also report. signal boosters for sale
  29. JHON | Aug 10, 2016
    I believe your site is precisely exactly what I've been searching for; this solutions a lot of associated with my personal queries.  Phenq diet Pills
  30. JHJON | Aug 10, 2016
    One of many blogs online, I like reading through your own probably the most a person provide all of us a lot data in a single little item.  top hip hop clubs in nyc
  31. Wimpernverlängerung Berlin, Wimpernverdichtung, Sugaring, Permanent Make up Guinot Kosmetik Mitte | Aug 10, 2016
    I agree with your blog and i will be back to check it more in the future so please keep up your work. Michael kors outlet love your content & the way that you write. shellac
  32. Link building | Aug 10, 2016
    If you're looking for excellent Workers.We are here to provide Internet Marketing services and help people. We offer High PR Backlinks, Website Traffic,blacklinks Service. We can rank you for any keyword on Google I will be very happy to offer my service to you. Please feel free to message me and talk about any queries.
  33. JHON | Aug 09, 2016
    Looking through a person's blogs and forums would make people prefer to publish progressively more. I did so your we appeared to be really happy by using. Them aren't executed to the place nonetheless it’s striking. I'll give you actually the hyperlinks so you're able to look at them to do allow me to explain imagination. cccam server
  34. Test de Paternité | Aug 09, 2016
    I should say only that it's awesome! The blog is informational and always produce amazing things. test paternite
  35. JOhn | Aug 08, 2016
    What an extraordinary site, thank you for giving me a chance to remark on it.  stavba domu
  36. Binadroid 2 Review - "Binadroid 2" Scam? Yes! Here's Better Alternate! | Aug 04, 2016
    This is so beautiful and creative. I just love the colors and whoever gets it in the mail will be smiling. Binadroid 2
  37. David | Aug 04, 2016
    That might performance short-term, having said that it’s not much of a simple long-term respond to to get gentlemen who want to possibly be because of this 1 exceptional women that they can’t discontinue taking into account. Maximus Profits Review
  38. Port Ghalib - Diving | Aug 02, 2016
    You have raised an important issue...Thanks for sharing.I would like to read more current affairs from this blog..keep posting. egypt snorkeling
  39. Agustina Montandon | Jul 31, 2016
    twitter followers I really like ones own blog post. It will be decent to find one explain in words belonging to the core and even purity in this particular very important area of interest will be readily experienced. buy youtube likes
  40. Galilea Galilea | Jul 30, 2016
    free instagram likes I should say only that its awesome! The blog is informational and always produce amazing things. free instagram followers
  41. jams jimmy | Jul 30, 2016
    Anything you perceived is definitely perfect, have an understanding of you should break up a rapport amongst already present definite plus innovative. Always be wary while you cure a definite along at the outer surface, for the reason that often there's a simple an opportunity to break up. Few improved to achieve the enable connected with an qualified. Bogota Recreacionistas
  42. David | Jul 28, 2016
    That is the reason focus on you must specific groundwork well before authoring. Will be possible to more desirable blog post in this manner. Jual MSI gaming
  43. Connie | Jul 23, 2016
    commercial real estate south Florida commercial real estate south Florida
  44. Sara Bannerman | May 12, 2016
    How Michael you can say that lord is only present on that place? If he is really your lord then he should be present everywhere. The best uk essay writing services is good for searching the answers of your quires. How stupidly the people are making the folks about their own religion.
  45. guy wilcox | Jun 11, 2013
    The experience of transcendence, I was taught years ago and still agree, is real and life-changing.  That experience, however, has never been unhitched from the nerve tissue of a brain--mine, yours, Jesus's, or the brains of assembled kin (seized by the Spirit).  This avoids (my) having to posit a supernatural theology.  The Mysterium Tremendum is the spirit of this creation, akin to the fragrance or the stench of a flower, and no less mysterious or awful or healing. 

    Where is God?  In human consciousness.  And in the consciousness of the stars?  But not wholly other.  As vulnerable as creation, as life, with sacred memories.  Yet always new.  Abba.  There and now.
  46. Barbara Roche | Jun 11, 2013
    Reading Barbara Brown Taylor's romantic meeting of God (or God meeting us) under shady oaks, etc., brought to mind a Navajo woman, in her 90s, whom I met 20 years ago.  She told me she was raised in the Navajo culture/religion until a teenager. It was a life of superstition and fear. She was destined to marry an older man and be his second wife. With her mother's help she got to the Christian mission and made the break from this encroaching enfeebling life.  I met her at the General Assembly when she was honored for her years of service.  I went to Arizona to interview her for Horizons.  She knew first hand the winds of the desert, the beauty of the mesas, the herding of the lambs, but she knew the terror of superstition and the shaman's expectations for a young woman. It was the Christian message that freed her.  I am sure that is what you are suggesting in the rest of your blog. However, we can get carried away thinking that we will just automatically "know" the loving God by sitting beside a lake.  I am grateful for the theologians who attempt to enlighten our minds and open the channels for God's grace. 

    There you have it.  Barbara


  47. Howard W. "Skip" Smith | Jun 11, 2013
    Reading this blog, I was reminded that my generation of seminarians at LPTS were challenged to "do theology" not to "learn theology"

    Leave a comment

    • 1044 Alta Vista Road |
    • Louisville, KY 40205 |
    • 800.264.1839 |
    • Fax: 502.895.1096 |
    • Site Map
    © Louisville Presbyterian Theological Seminary